Ancestry suggests children:Reuben 1822, Sarah Ann 1823, Mary 1830, Elizabeth 1832, Benjamin 1833-1915, David 1836, Margaret 1838, Amanda 1841, Lovina 1844
Many of the children show in records and together but unconfirmed they were all children of Valentine. It appears wide Mary Margaret is in the home in CA 1870 with Lovina; Lovina and Amanda appear in the home of brother Reuben in CA. Benjamin (a Benjamin sponsored baptism of Sarah Ann) named first son Valentine in 1854 in Nebraska.

Sponsors for Sarah Anna baptism were Ana Maria Schiller and Benjamin Schiffler

WILL “State of Indiana Marshall County - Sarah A Bailey, been duly sworn upon her oath says that Valentine Shuffler late of said county died Interstate on or about the sixth day of April 1855, leaving no real estate and that his personal property does not probably amount to $300 and that Margaret Shuffler the widow of said decedent is living and desires that the clerk aappoint an appraiser in accordance with the statute in such case…” Sworn by Sarah A Bailey 23 Apr 1855