1850 Saltcreek, Hocking, Ohio Catherine 26 OH in the home with Solomon Riggle 39 and Mary 37 and Riggle children. (Mary could be her sister)
—Both a Solomon Stump 43 PA and Dunkle family near by).
1860 Catherine 37 OH is a domestic in the home of Solomon Reigel 49 and Mary 47 and children.
— George Dunkle 49 OH family next door and in home is Samuel Dunkle 48 PA

1870 Stringtown, Pickaway, Ohio Alfred 39 and Catharine Stump 47
1870 Colerain, Ross, Ohio with Barbara Hettinger 74 PA and Lewis Dunkle 23 OH

In 1900 census there is both a Catharine Dunkle Nov 1830 in Washington Pickaway and a Catharina Stumpf Feb 1822 in the census in Saltcreek Pickaway Co. OH NOT THE SAME WOMAN

1900 Saltcreek, Pickaway, Ohio Alfred Stumpf 69 born Jan 1831 OH both parents PA and Catharine 78 Feb 1822 born OH, father PA mother OH; married 36 years and 1 of 1 child living;

DC cites parents as John Hettinger and Barbara
Informant on DC was Floyd Dunkle and her name is Catharine STUMP
Buried Stumpf Cemetery
Others trees say she md Dunkle 1852 and Stumpf 1864. But these are different women - Catherine had brief marriage or had son by Dunkle out or wedlock
THERE IS A LEWIS AGE 3 IN THE HOME OF BARBARA AND JOHN IN 1850 but never lives with Catherine, he is with Barbara in 1990 as Lewis Dunkle

1870 Colerain, Ross, Ohio with Barbara Hettinger 74 PA and Lewis Dunkle 23 OH